The Methodist Parsonage: A Historic Home at 49 Second Avenue, Uxbridge

At the corner of Second Avenue and Dominion Street stands a house with deep roots in Uxbridge’s history—the Methodist Parsonage, now recognized as part of the United Church. More than just a residence, this home has long symbolized faith, fellowship, and the strength of community ties.

This photo taken in 2025 shows the house as seen from the corner of Dominion Street and Second Avenue.

A Beginning in 1878

In 1878, the trustees of the Methodist Parsonage acquired the property from Joseph Gould, a key figure in Uxbridge’s early development. They commissioned the construction of a red brick home, designed with both elegance and purpose. Its striking six gothic-style windows and a sweeping verandah gave it a sense of grandeur, fitting for a home connected to the spiritual and social life of the town.

.

This photo taken in 2022 shows the house as seen from the corner of Dominion Street and Second Avenue.

Changes Through the Years

Like many historic homes, the Methodist Parsonage has evolved over time. The once expansive verandah was reduced in size, and the rich red brick exterior was eventually painted yellow and now white. Decorative features that once highlighted its Victorian charm—such as gingerbread trim, roof finials, shutters, and tall chimneys—were removed. Yet despite these changes, the home has retained its historic character and continues to reflect the spirit of its era.

.

The above photo courtesy of Uxbridge – Scugog Historic Homes and Heritage Buildings by Paul Arculus and J. Peter Hvidsten was taken from Joseph Gould’s photo album and shows what the Methodist Parsonage looked like in 1899.

A House of Resilience and Community

The Methodist Parsonage has seen many seasons of life—welcoming families, hosting gatherings, and standing quietly through times of both celebration and sorrow. While the details of its architecture have shifted, its role as a symbol of resilience and fellowship remains strong. It embodies the values of the Methodist and later United Church community: connection, service, and shared history.

.

This photo showing the south facade of the house was taken from a post card circa 1910. Courtesy of Uxbridge – Scugog Historic Homes and Heritage Buildings by Paul Arculus and J. Peter Hvidsten

A Living Reminder

Today, 49 Second Avenue still carries the charm of its past. Though altered, the home’s essence endures, offering a reminder of the people who lived within its walls and the community it served. It stands not just as a historic house, but as a living reminder of Uxbridge’s heritage, bridging the gap between the town’s past and present.

Want to learn about other Historic Homes in Uxbridge?  Follow our Uxbridge Historic Homes Blog